Four seasons, 40 episodes, one Enterprise
Four seasons in, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is the most argued-about show in the franchise — and still the best thing modern Star Trek has made. Since its debut on Paramount+ in 2022, the series has taken Captain Christopher Pike’s USS Enterprise through 40 episodes across four 10-episode seasons: season one in 2022, season two in 2023, season three in 2025, and season four, which ran July 23 to September 24, 2026. A fifth and final season of just six episodes is expected in 2027, bringing the total to 46. That makes now the right moment to take stock — because the show’s greatest strength and its biggest problem are the same thing.
Season 1: The high-water mark
The first season arrived as a relief. After the serialized sprawl of Discovery and Picard, here was Star Trek doing what it used to do: a different strange new world every week, a problem to solve, a moral question with no easy answer. Anson Mount’s Pike — warm, wry, carrying the knowledge of his own fated future — anchored a cast that clicked immediately: Ethan Peck’s Spock, Rebecca Romijn’s Una Chin-Riley, Celia Rose Gooding’s Uhura, Jess Bush’s Chapel, Christina Chong’s La’an, Melissa Navia’s Ortegas. The finale, “A Quality of Mercy,” reimagined the classic “Balance of Terror” with a visit from a young James T. Kirk, and it worked. Critics were near-unanimous, and the show picked up two Saturn Awards and two Emmy nominations along the way. If the series had simply repeated season one four times, this review would be very short.
Season 2: The high-wire act
Season two is where the show started showing off — and mostly getting away with it. “Those Old Scientists” crossed over with the animated Lower Decks and was pure joy. “Subspace Rhapsody” turned the whole ship into a musical and somehow made it moving. “Under the Cloak of War” gave M’Benga and Ortegas a harrowing Klingon War reckoning that was as serious as anything the franchise has done. The season ended on a Gorn cliffhanger, “Hegemony,” that left the crew in real jeopardy. Not everything landed — the tonal whiplash between episodes could be jarring — but the ambition was the point, and the cast was strong enough to sell almost anything.
Season 3: The wobble
Season three, delayed seven months by the 2023 writers’ and actors’ strikes, was the first real stumble. The reception was noticeably colder than the first two seasons: critics still rated it around 88 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, but the audience score fell to roughly half that. The standouts were genuine — “Four-and-a-Half Vulcans” showed off Peck and Romijn at their best, “Wedding Bell Blues” reintroduced Trelane as a Q in a way that actually worked, and “What Is Starfleet?” told a story through a journalist’s eyes. But the season also introduced the holodeck decades too early, leaned harder into comedy and genre pastiche, and ended with “New Life and New Civilizations,” in which Captain Marie Batel gave her life to save the crew — an episode written as a potential series finale in case the show wasn’t renewed. It felt like a show unsure what it wanted to be.
Season 4: The gimmick season
Season four, the last full-length season, doubled down on the thing that divided season three: nearly every episode is a genre exercise. The rundown tells the story — “Valles Marineris” sends the crew back to the age of dinosaurs and an ancient Martian civilization; “The Griffin Incident” is straight space horror in the Event Horizon mold; “Human Best Friend” is The Hangover on shore leave; “A Case of Chiaroscuro” is a black-and-white noir; “Level-Five Transporter Accident” turns the crew into puppets; “Off-Hour” is a real-time disaster movie; “Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass” is a soap opera; “Orders of Magnitude” is a Cold War submarine thriller; “Once La’an a Time” is a fairytale; and the finale, “Tomorrow’s Enterprise,” is a time-travel two-hander.
Critics split hard. Space.com called it a season of gimmicks that was “afraid to say anything,” arguing only two episodes — “Off-Hour” and “Orders of Magnitude” — were executed well. Others loved it outright, and at least one reviewer called it the strongest season since the first. Both reactions are fair. The best episodes of the season are genuinely excellent: “Valles Marineris” is a big-swing science-fiction idea with real stakes, and “Orders of Magnitude” is the kind of thorny, character-driven political story classic Trek was built on, with real growth for Jim Kirk. The weaker ones feel like the writers reaching for a joke or a homage first and a story second — the puppet episode is funny for about ten minutes, and the soap-opera hour is a slog even with Rhys Darby back.
Spoiler warning for the finale: “Tomorrow’s Enterprise” puts Uhura at the center of two timelines, jumping between Pike’s Enterprise and Kirk’s Enterprise a year in the future, where Scotty dies aboard a shuttle in a black hole — and is saved by a plot involving a cosmic “space baby” and the beings who call themselves the Midwives. It is, by any measure, ridiculous. It is also the most emotionally effective episode of the season, carried by Celia Rose Gooding playing both versions of Uhura, and it does something the show has been building toward for four years: it lets us see Kirk’s Enterprise, with poker on the mess deck and a captain still learning his distance from the crew, as the destination this whole series has been sailing toward. Hopes that the finale was a backdoor pilot for a proposed Star Trek: Year One series were dashed by showrunner Akiva Goldsman — but as a statement of where the show is headed, it works.
What’s working, what’s not
Working: the cast, full stop. Mount, Peck, Gooding, Romijn and the rest are the best ensemble in modern Trek, and the show’s willingness to let episodes belong to one character is its secret weapon. The production values are feature-film quality, and the episodic format — a different story every week — remains the right call. When the show trusts a classic Star Trek story, as in “Orders of Magnitude” or “Off-Hour,” it is as good as anything the franchise has produced this century.
Not working: the gimmick habit. In a 10-episode season, every comedy or homage episode is a tenth of the year, and the misses hurt more than they did in the 26-episode seasons of old. The show sometimes confuses referencing a genre with having something to say in it, and season four’s boldest swings occasionally land as “wouldn’t it be fun if” rather than “here’s a story only Star Trek can tell.” The through-lines also suffer: with so many standalone experiments, the bigger arcs — Pike’s fate, the road to Kirk — have to fight for room.
The verdict
Four seasons in, Strange New Worlds is a great show that keeps getting in its own way — and the balance still tips firmly in its favor. Season by season: season one is a near-classic, season two a thrilling high-wire act, season three an uneven stumble, season four a flawed but frequently wonderful swing. The finale’s promise is that the six remaining episodes will be more focused — Goldsman has said the show is trending toward “a much more singular sci-fi, action-adventure, emotional storytelling” as it closes the circle to The Original Series. If it delivers on that, the series will end as the defining Star Trek of its era. If it doesn’t, it will still be the one that reminded everyone what the franchise feels like when it works.
Overall: 4 out of 5 stars. Flawed, funny, occasionally infuriating — and still boldly going.
All four seasons of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds are streaming on Paramount+. The six-episode fifth and final season is expected in 2027.
